538 Route 25A

Rocky Point, NY 11778

Built in 1963, this well-maintained commercial property offers over 3580 sq. ft. of versatile space divided into five suites (currently configured as four). A rare opportunity to own a stable, income-producing property with long-term tenants, strong visibility, and a proven rental history in a high-traffic area. Property Overview - Total Area: 3,580 sq. ft. Configuration: 5 suites (4 active, 1 vacant). Parking: 17 total spaces (front, south side, and rear). Exterior Renovations (2021): new windows, siding, and doors. Rear Boundary: Faces the scenic Pine Barrens for added privacy and a natural backdrop. Location: High-visibility area where the bypass meets Route 25A, close to major retailers, restaurants, and commuter routes. Current Tenancies -"Suite 1" – Liquor Store: 1,125 sq. ft. with storage, bath, and rear entry. Separate HVAC and dedicated oil tank. Lease expires 01/2029. "Suites 2 & 3" – Computer Repair: 1,159 sq. ft. with storage rooms, bath, and rear entry. Lease expires 04/2027. "Suite 4" – Insurance Office: 550 sq. ft. with 2 offices, bath, and rear entry. Lease expires 04/2026. Suites 2-5 share oil tank. "Suite 5" – Vacant / Recently Remodeled: 550 sq. ft. featuring 2 offices, bath, and rear entry. Move-in ready for an owner-occupant or new tenant. Financial & Utility Details - Landlord currently Pays: Oil for Suites 2–5, Taxes and water for all suites. All building maintenance. Tenants Pay: Electricity for their individual suites. Trash removal (not provided by landlord) . Heating: Suite 1 has a separate HVAC and oil tank. Highlights for Landlords & Investors: Long-term tenants with staggered lease expirations. One recently renovated, vacant suite for an owner-user or immediate lease-up. Low-maintenance exterior with major updates completed in 2021. Strong traffic counts and excellent exposure at the Route 25A bypass. Ideal 1031 Exchange or portfolio addition.

Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker Reliable R E gina@ginabettenhauser.com


Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of 2025-11-10 04:33 AM EST. All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.