Properties

Save
Ask
Tour
Hide
Share
$695,990
27 Days On Site

21 W Bartlett Road
Middle Island, NY 11953

For Sale|Single Family Residence|Active
2
Beds
2
Total Baths
2
Full Baths
1,489
SqFt
$467
/SqFt
1968
Built
County:
Suffolk
Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker Reliable R E gina@ginabettenhauser.com
Call Now: (631) 727-3713
Is this the listing for you? We can help make it yours.
(631) 727-3713
Upcoming Open Houses
Sun, Aug 31, 2:30 PM - 4:00 PM
21 W Bartlett Road21 W Bartlett Road21 W Bartlett Road21 W Bartlett Road
Save
Ask
Tour
Hide
Share

Mortgage Calculator

Monthly Payment (Est.)

$3,175
Calculator powered by Showcase IDX, a Constellation1 Company. Copyright ©2025 Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Welcome to your private waterfront retreat where serenity meets modern living. Tucked away on 1.45 landscaped acres, this one-of-a-kind 2-bedroom, 2-bath home offers a rare combination of peaceful seclusion, upgraded comfort, and natural beauty. If you're searching for a home that feels like a getaway—but with everyday convenience—this is the one you've been waiting for. Initially built in 1968 and thoughtfully updated throughout the years, the home exudes warmth and charm from the moment you step inside. The main level features refinished oak floors flowing into an expansive 20’ x 30’ living room, where soaring cathedral ceilings and window-wrapped walls invite in an abundance of natural light and frame stunning views of the pond and lush specimen plantings. The open-concept kitchen and dining area is made for gathering—upgraded appliances, a water-view table setting, and direct access to a cozy sunroom create a space where meals feel like a retreat. From there, step out to the impressive 60-foot Trex deck, complete with two sitting areas and a wooden pergola—perfect for entertaining, relaxing, or watching the seasons unfold. Down the hall, the primary bedroom offers peaceful views, newly installed oak flooring, a walk-in closet, and access to a shared bath. The secondary bedroom is generously sized with two closets and easy access to a second full bath featuring a dual sink vanity and extra storage. Need more space? The walk-out basement includes a versatile finished studio with a private entrance—perfect for guests, hobbies, or a home office. There’s also a 2-car detached garage with workshop space, overhead storage, and new motion lights—ideal for DIYers or hobbyists. This home is packed with thoughtful upgrades that enhance the home's long-term value and efficiency: Fujitsu heat pumps (2020) for efficient heating & cooling, Tankless water heater (2020), New PEX plumbing and faucets (2022), New roof (2025) with transferable 20-year warranty and Anderson sliding glass door, re-stained siding, updated entryway, attic insulation & more. Step outside and enjoy your kettle hole pond—shared with just two neighbors—perfect for boating, kayaking, fishing, or simply soaking in the peaceful vibes. The land is filled with mature hardwoods, ornamental grasses, and native plants, all thoughtfully maintained in a fully fenced setting. Tucked in a 10-acre zoning district, privacy is guaranteed, and the location is unbeatable: minutes to Spring Lake Golf Course, multiple transportation methods, vineyards, farm stands, shopping, dining, and some of the best beaches and waterfront amenities. From sunrise coffees on the porch to golden hour views from the deck, this home offers a lifestyle you won’t find anywhere else. Come explore the magic of waterfront living—schedule your visit today. Homes like this don’t come around often.

Save
Ask
Tour
Hide
Share
Listing Snapshot
Price 
$695,990
Days On Site 
27 Days
Bedrooms 
2
Inside Area (SqFt) 
1,489 sqft
Total Baths 
2
Full Baths 
2
Partial Baths 
N/A
Lot Size 
1.45 Acres
Year Built 
1968
MLS® Number 
894837
Status 
Active
Property Tax 
$9,476.04
HOA/Condo/Coop Fees 
N/A
Sq Ft Source 
N/A
Friends & Family
Recent Activity
4 weeks agoListing first seen on site
4 weeks agoListing updated with changes from the MLS®
General Features
Acres 
1.45
Garage 
Yes
Garage Spaces 
2
Parking 
DrivewayGarage
Property Sub Type 
Single Family Residence
Sewer 
Cesspool
SqFt Total 
1489
Style 
Exp Ranch
Utilities 
Cable AvailableElectricity Connected
Water Source 
PrivateWell
Interior Features
Appliances 
Gas RangeRefrigerator
Basement 
Level - LowerDescription - Walkout lower level with window wrapped wall overlooking patio and pond, huge storage with egress windows. Laundry and well house
Cooling 
Ductless
Heating 
ElectricENERGY STAR Qualified EquipmentSee Remarks
Interior 
Cathedral Ceiling(s)Eat-in Kitchen
Auxiliary Room 
Level - FirstDescription - Sunroom with entry from Dining Area - french door entry to deck and yard
Bathroom 1 
Level - FirstDescription - Hall & Primary bedroom entry, double sink vanity, tub/shower , 2 closets
Bedroom 1 
Level - FirstDescription - 2 closets
Kitchen 
Level - FirstDescription - Propane Gas Range, refrigerator and Dining Area
Living Room 
Level - FirstDescription - 20 x 30 Living Room with vaulted ceiling, window wrapped wall over private pond, expansive Trex deck, entry to rear yard
Primary Bedroom 
Level - FirstDescription - Wood floors, walk-in closet and bath entry
Save
Ask
Tour
Hide
Share
Exterior Features
Construction Details 
Cedar
Exterior 
Garden
Lot Features 
GardenLandscapedPrivate
Patio And Porch 
DeckPatioPorch
Waterfront Features 
PondWaterfront Access
Community Features
School District 
Longwood
Schools
School District
Longwood
Elementary School
West Middle Island School
Middle School
Longwood Junior High School
High School
Longwood High School
Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker Reliable R E gina@ginabettenhauser.com


Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of 2025-08-28 11:59 AM EDT. All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.

Neighborhood & Commute
Source: Walkscore
Community information and market data Powered by ATTOM Data Solutions. Copyright ©2019 ATTOM Data Solutions. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
Save
Ask
Tour
Hide
Share