Properties

Save
Ask
Tour
Hide
Share
$850,000
22 Days On Site

537 Bay 5th Street
West Islip, NY 11795

For Sale|Single Family Residence|Pending
5
Beds
3
Total Baths
3
Full Baths
2,534
SqFt
$335
/SqFt
1965
Built
Subdivision:
Willets Point / Babylon Beach Estates
County:
Suffolk
Listing courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate Michelle.Sullivan@Elliman.com
Call Now: (631) 727-3713
Is this the listing for you? We can help make it yours.
(631) 727-3713
537 Bay 5th Street537 Bay 5th Street537 Bay 5th Street537 Bay 5th Street
Save
Ask
Tour
Hide
Share

Mortgage Calculator

Monthly Payment (Est.)

$3,878
Calculator powered by Showcase IDX, a Constellation1 Company. Copyright ©2025 Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

This Custom-Built, Wide-Line Hi-Ranch is located in one of West Islip’s most desirable beach and boating communities. Designed for social gatherings, it features spacious living and dining room with original hardwood floors throughout. Natural light pours into the primary bedroom that includes a walk-in closet and en-suite bathroom. Two additional south-facing bedrooms on the upper level offer abundant natural light as well. The eat-in kitchen boasts quartz countertops and new flooring, with a hidden staircase leading to a sizable backyard and the lower level. The lower level includes a jumbo-sized living space with a wood-burning fireplace and sliding doors leading to the patio. Two additional bedrooms/multi-purpose rooms are perfect to accommodate your lifestyle, plus the updated full bathroom make it perfect for hosting extended family and friends. Residents have the option to join an exclusive beach association, which offers a private clubhouse on the Great South Bay, a secluded beach with spectacular views of the Robert Moses Bridge, and a boat basin with docking slips to accommodate most vessels. If you enjoy ocean beaches, boating, and leisure time in quaint villages, this peaceful home is perfect for you. It’s near to excellent restaurants, performing arts centers, seasonal farmers markets, dog park, walking/hiking trails, boutique shops and so much more. Additionally, it's convenient to hospitals and major highways. Experience South Shore living at its finest!

Save
Ask
Tour
Hide
Share
Listing Snapshot
Price 
$850,000
Days On Site 
22 Days
Bedrooms 
5
Inside Area (SqFt) 
2,534 sqft
Total Baths 
3
Full Baths 
3
Partial Baths 
N/A
Lot Size 
0.23 Acres
Year Built 
1965
MLS® Number 
883418
Status 
Pending
Property Tax 
$18,613.56
HOA/Condo/Coop Fees 
N/A
Sq Ft Source 
N/A
Friends & Family
Recent Activity
5 days agoStatus changed to Pending
5 days agoListing updated with changes from the MLS®
3 weeks agoListing first seen on site
General Features
Acres 
0.23
Cross Street 
Between Secatogue Ln. & Center Bay Drive
Direction Faces 
South
Disclosures 
Lead Paint, Seller Property Disclosure
Garage 
Yes
Garage Spaces 
1
Parking 
DrivewayGaragePrivate
Parking Spaces 
4
Property Sub Type 
Single Family Residence
Sewer 
Public Sewer
SqFt Total 
2570
Style 
Hi Ranch
Utilities 
Natural Gas AvailableElectricity ConnectedNatural Gas ConnectedSewer ConnectedWater Connected
Water Source 
Public
Interior Features
Appliances 
DryerElectric RangeRefrigeratorStainless Steel Appliance(s)Washer
Cooling 
Central Air
Fireplace 
Yes
Fireplace Features 
Family RoomMasonryWood Burning
Fireplaces 
1
Flooring 
CarpetCombinationHardwoodLaminate
Heating 
Baseboard
Interior 
Double VanityDry BarEat-in KitchenSoaking TubStorageWalk-In Closet(s)
Laundry Features 
InsideLaundry Room
Family Room 
Level - LowerDescription - LOWER LEVEL: Den w/Wood Burning Fireplace & Access to Patio, Full Bathroom, 2 Bedrooms, Access to Garage, Laundry/Utility Room.
Living Room 
Level - FirstDescription - MAIN LEVEL: Living Room, Dining Room, EIK, Hallway Closets/Attic Access & Full Bath, Primary Ensuite and 2 Additional Bedrooms.
Save
Ask
Tour
Hide
Share
Exterior Features
Construction Details 
BlockBrick
Exterior 
Other
Fencing 
FencedBack YardOther
Lot Features 
Back YardFront YardLandscapedLevel
Patio And Porch 
PatioPorch
View 
Neighborhood
Waterview 
Neighborhood
Community Features
Association Amenities 
Boat DockClubhouseOtherPowered Boats Allowed
Community Features 
ClubhouseOther
HOA Fee Frequency 
Annually
School District 
West Islip
Schools
School District
West Islip
Elementary School
Paul J Bellew Elementary School
Middle School
Beach Street Middle School
High School
West Islip Senior High School
Listing courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate Michelle.Sullivan@Elliman.com


Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of 2025-08-27 05:49 AM EDT. All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.

Neighborhood & Commute
Source: Walkscore
Community information and market data Powered by ATTOM Data Solutions. Copyright ©2019 ATTOM Data Solutions. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
Save
Ask
Tour
Hide
Share